Technology news and Jobs 
Information Technology News US Attorney General proposes crackdown on copyright infringement
Information Technology News US Attorney General proposes crackdown on copyright infringement | US Attorney General proposes crackdown on copyright infringement |
|
|
|
| Written by Stephen Withers | |
| Thursday, 17 May 2007 | |
|
But if that person attempts to sell or give away any of those copies, the situation changes. Whatever the circumstances, and quite apart from any civil case the copyright owner might be entitled to bring, there is an element of 'passing off'. Even though in the case of digital content the copy might be a perfect bit-for-bit replica, or an item of clothing might be made in the same factory using the same patterns, processes and raw materials are the authorised product, there is still a sense in which they are not 'the real thing'. It seems to me that the public interest would be better served by specifically strengthening laws against counterfeiting rather than this more general reference to intellectual property. The danger comes from fake medical equipment, automotive parts, drugs, electrical equipment and so on, which can have a very real impact on people's health and safety. To be fair, the proposed changes do emphasise this aspect (and the life sentence would apply where the copying "recklessly or knowingly causes or attempts to cause death"), but lumping them in with measures that could conceivably be used against an individual that uses BitTorrent to download an unauthorised copy of a TV show because they forget to set their PVR the night before is hardly likely to foster public support. And the new penalties would include "forfeiture [of] any property used or intended to be used in any manner or part to commit or facilitate the commission of a Federal copyright infringement offense". Where will the courts draw the line in interpreting this? If Mr and Ms Public fear they might lose their computer - let alone their house - for a trivial and commonplace activity, you can bet they'll be setting their elected representatives on notice rather than changing their habits. Worryingly, the proposal comes close to creating a 'thoughtcrime' by making it a criminal offence to attempt to infringe copyright. A person who makes a copy that they think is infringing perhaps could be found guilty even if the copying is actually legitimate because the original is out of copyright or some exemption applies. Sometimes a sledgehammer is the right tool to fix a problem - but when it isn't, using one results in additional damage.{moscomment}
Get stories like this delivered daily - FREE - subscribe now When you subscribe get a 12 months license for LiveProject Valued at $99 USD  Download the FREE iTWire desktop alert widget
  |
Tags
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|
Subscribe to iTWire's daily e-newsletter now and get a FREE 12 month license to project management software valued at $99 USD. 
