Australian IT JOBS : Sydney IT jobs, UNIX jobs, Linux jobs, Java jobs, ASP jobs Linux.conf.au Linux.conf.au
Technology news and Jobs arrow Technology Lifestyle arrow CES 2008: Logitech Harmony One universal remote control - REVIEW
CES 2008: Logitech Harmony One universal remote control - REVIEW PDF Print E-mail
Written by Adam Turner   
Sunday, 06 January 2008
The Harmony One's only highlighted new software feature is the ability to set up a favourite TV channels list, which is displayed after you run the "watch live TV" Activity. You can fit six favourites buttons on one screen and you can even allocate them a customised JPEG (either from Logitech's list or of your own creation).

[Update: This feature is also available on the Harmony 785 using software v7.4.0]

Perhaps more useful is the addition of a "return to Current Activity" soft button. This allows you to execute an Activity such as "Watch DVD", then navigate away from the DVD remote control screen to a Device screen (such as your amplifier) and then return to the DVD remote screen whilst still in Activity mode. Previous Logitech remotes such as the Harmony 785 offered no way of returning to an Activity once you navigated away. This meant if you wanted to go back to controlling the DVD player in such circumstances you either had to execute the "Watch DVD" Activity again (and perhaps lose your place in the movie) or switch to the DVD player under Device mode (which meant the remote no longer tracked your commands). Such a useful new feature is the only tantalising taste of what we hoped the Harmony One might offer. Hopefully it will be retrospectively added to other Harmony remotes via a software upgrade.

[Update: You can return to the previous Activity on the 785 or 525 by pressing the Activities button twice. All that's new on the Harmony One is giving this function its own button.]

Such new features are a nice touch Considering there are no new features, we doubt there's enough to lure people away from the Harmony 785 or 880 - which have a considerably cheaper street price. Why can't you set favourites for other Activities on the Harmony One? Why can't you customise the look of other buttons? Such things would help compensate for the loss of the four programmable colour function buttons found on the Harmony 785.
 
All up the Harmony One is a rather disappointing for those familiar with the Harmony range and expecting a complete overhaul. Had Logitech dubbed it the Harmony 900 we might not be so critical, but when you optfor a name like the Harmony One you really are implying perfection. So much work has gone into the hardware redesign - it was even named a 2008 CES Innovations award winner for excellence in design and engineering - yet so little work has gone into the interface.

The Harmony One might look sleek and sexy, but sadly Logitech has done stuff-all to address the shortcomings of the earlier Harmony models. It's even taken a few steps backwards such as limiting the number of Activities or Devices displayed at once to a paltry three. Hopefully future software upgrades will address such issues. Meanwhile the Harmony One might look great, but it's not the One remote control to rule them all.

Logitech's Harmony One universal remote control retails for $AU399.95 ($US249.99). For more details visit www.logitech.com

OPINION: Logitech's Harmony One remote control was not carried down the CES mountain by Moses

Logitech's Remote Control Business Unit product manager Alex Zaliauskas has confirmed the accuracy of my points.


{moscomment}


Get stories like this delivered daily - FREE - subscribe now
When you subscribe get a 12 months license for LiveProject
Valued at $99 USD


LiveWire - Desktop alerts Download the FREE iTWire desktop alert widget LiveWire - Desktop alerts


Del.icio.us!


 
< Prev   Next >

Latest jobs

Contact , Register , Advertise with iTWire , Links , Register , About iTWire , Feedback , Post your jobs , Events , iTWire site map , Start Blogging
Industry Releases , Submit your release now , Start submitting to iTWire , How to post video